On behalf of the undersigned groups, we submit the following comments on the City of Benicia’s Final Environmental Impact Report (Final EIR) for the Valero Benicia Crude-by-Rail Project (the Project). The City released a Draft EIR for public comment in June 2014. After receiving numerous comments pointing out the deficiencies in the Draft EIR, the City recirculated the Revised Draft EIR in August 2015. The City published a Final EIR, which includes responses to comments, on January 5, 2016.